The Prince of Darkness is a gentleman (King Lear, Act III, Scene iv)

Oh, Reaper, I want to marry you and become a Bride of Satan. If the CW cancels you, instead of sending bras, tabasco, or peanuts to the network, fans could call upon the Devil to force them to bring it back. (We could also send root beer, but I like the idea of summoning the Devil much better.)

[Poll #1066676]

In conclusion: Ray Wise.